A Few Strokes to the spiritual Portrait Hints of Uniate Archbishop Josaphat Kuntsevych
https://doi.org/10.53822/2712-9276-2021-2-97-118
Abstract
This article describes the main features of spiritual life of Uniate archbishop Josaphat Kuntsevych (1580–1623), who was killed by the rebellious citizens of Vitebsk because of his zeal in spreading uniatism. Through the efforts of the Uniates and Latins, he was declared a martyr in the name of Christ, the Catholic faith, and the holy union with the Roman Church. The author notes the difference of approaches to the interpretation of his personality in the context of the two confessional traditions: the Latin-Uniat and Orthodox. This article aims to objectively examine Kuntsevych’s spiritual image, based on the rules of monastic life peculiar to the Orthodox East. A wide range of sources have been studied: Kuntsevych’s writings and various historical accounts on the peculiarities of his missionary and pastoral activities, as well as the materials of the canonization process. It The results show that Josaphat Kuntsevych is an early example of the union’s Latinization. Under the Jesuits’s influence, he adopted an intolerant view of “schisma”. This led to an internal break from the Eastern spiritual tradition and its replacement with a surrogate of Catholic exercises and Orthodox fasts and prayers in the inner life. Lacking proper instruction at the beginning of his monastic journey, Kuntsevych indulged in reading and applied spiritual exercises guided by his own imagination. His zeal for asceticism in the spirit of Jesuit practices attracted the attention of others, and without the advice of a spiritual director, he was unable to develop self-criticism and true humility. His harshness to himself led to him treating others the same way. Kind and affectionate to submissive and agreeable listeners, Josaphat became intolerant and intrusive to dissenters. With a passionate desire for martyrdom, Josaphat followed the lessons of his Jesuit leaders, who saw death at the hands of infidels as the best means of converting them. In conclusion, Josaphat Kuntsevych affiliated himself internally with Latinism despite his outward adherence to the Eastern rites.
About the Author
A. S. Khoteev
HISTORICAL COMMISSION AT THE BYELARUSSIAN EXARCHATE OF THE RUSSIAN ORTHODOX CHURCH
Belarus
Belarus
Alexei Sergeevich Khoteev — priest, Associate of the Historical Commission at the Belarusian Exarchate, Candidate of Historical Sciences
220035, Minsk, Saperov str., 5
References
1. Archaeographic Commission (1851). Akty otnosyashchiyesya k istorii Zapadnoy Rossii [Acts of Western Russia]. (Vol. 4). St. Petersburg: Tipografiya Eduarda Pratsa. [In Russian].
2. Виленский учебный округ. Управление (1867). Arkheograficheskiy sbornik dokumentov otnosyashchikhsya k istorii Severo-Zapadnoy Rusi [Archeographic Collection of Documents Relating to the History of Northwestern Russia]. (Vol. 1). Vilna: Izd. Pri Upravlenii Vilenskogo uchebnogo okruga. [In Russian].
3. Vernikovskaya, E. A. (2002). Vitebskoye vosstaniye 12 noyabrya 1623 g. [The Vitebsk uprising of November 12, 1623]. In Slavyanskiy almanakh 2001 [Slavic Almanac 2001](pp. 108–132). Moscow. [In Russian].
4. Vernikovskaya, E. A. (2001). Iosafat Kuntsevich (1580–1623), Polotskiy arkhiyepiskop Greko-katolicheskoy Tserkvi [Josafat Kuntsevych (1580–1623), Polotsk archbishop of the Greek-Catholic Church]. In Slavyanskiy almanakh 2000 [Slavic Almanac 2000] (pp. 20–41). Moscow. [In Russian].
5. Govorskiy, K. (1865). Iosafat Kuntsevich, uniatskiy polotskiy arkhiepiskop [Josafat Kuntsevich, Uniate Archbishop of Polotsk]. Vilna. [In Russian].
6. Dobryanskiy, F. (1882). Opisanie rukopisey Vilenskoy publichnoy biblioteki [Description of the Manuscripts in the Public Library of Vilna]. Vilna. [In Russian].
7. Zhukovich, P. N. (1909). O neizdannykh sochineniyakh Iosafata Kuntsevicha [On the unpublished works of Josafat Kuntsevych]. Izvestiya Otdela russkogo yazyka i slovesnosti Akademii nauk [Proceedings of the Russian Language and Literature Department of the Academy of Sciences], 14(3), 199–231. [In Russian].
8. Kiprianovich, G. Ya. (1912). Arkhiepiskop Polotskiy I Vitebskiy Iosafat Kuntsevich, zapadno-russkiy muchenik za uniyu s Rimom (po novym nauchnym dannym) [Archbishop of Polotsk and Vitebsk Josafat Kuntsevych, a Western-Russian martyr for unia with Rome (according to new scientific data)]. Vestnik Vilenskogo Svyato-Dukhovskogo bratstva [Bulletin of the Vilna Orthodox Svyato-Dukhovsky Brotherhood], (8–10), 137–139, 157–159, 175–179. [In Russian].
9. Koyalovich, M. O. (1861). Litovskaya tserkovnaya uniya [The Lithuanian Church Union] (Vol. 2). St. Petersburg: tip. dukhovnogo zhurn. “Strannik”. [In Russian].
10. Kudryk, V. (1948). Zhittya Yosafata Kuntsevicha: Іstorichna rozvіdka na pіdstavі katolitskikh dzherel [The Life of Josaphat Kuntsevych: Historical Discourse based on Catholic Journals]. Winnipeg: Vidavnicha spіlka “Yeklezіya”. [In Ukrainian].
11. Opisanie dokumentov arkhiva zapadno-russkikh uniatskikh mitropolitov [Description of the Documents from the Archives of the Western Russian Uniate Metropolitans]. (1897). (Vol. 1). St. Petersburg: Sinod. tip. [In Russian].
12. Pisaniya muzhey apostolskikh [Writings of the Apostolic Men]. (2008). Izdatelskiy Sovet Russkoy Pravoslavnoy Tserkvi. [In Russian].
13. Sapunov, A. P. (1883). Vitebskaya starina [Vitebsk Antiquity] (Vol. 1). Vitebsk: Tipografiya gubernskogo upravleniya. [In Russian].
14. Senik, S. (1994). Dukhovniy profіl svyatogoYosafata Kuntsevicha [The Spiritual Profile of St. Josaphat Kuntsevych]. Lviv: Svіchado. [In Russian].
15. Soloviy, M. M., Velikiy A. G. (1967). Svyatiy Yosafat Kuntsevich. Yogo zhittya і doba [St. Josophat Kuntsevych. His Life and Work]. Toronto. [In Ukrainian].
16. Fedin, A. V. (2021). “Dorogami, polnymi krestov…”: iezuitskoe missionerskoe muchenichestvo v XVII v. [“By Roads Full of Crosses...”: Jesuit Missionary Martyrdom in the 17th Century]. Dialog so vremenem [Dialogue with time], 40, 173–201. [In Russian].
17. Khoynatskiy, A. (priest). (1882). Pravoslavie I uniya v litse dvukh svoikh zashchitnikov, prepodobnogo Iova Pochaevskogo I Iosafata Kuntsevicha [Orthodoxy and Uniate in the Face of Its Two Defenders, St. Job Pochaevsky and Josaphat Kuntsevich]. Trudy Kievskoy dukhovnoy akademii [Proceedings of the Kiev Theological Academy], 2(8), 409–426; 3(9), 52–72. [In Russian].
18. Khoteev, A. (2015). Perepiska kantslera Lva Sapegi I arkhiepiskopa Iosafata Kuntsevicha [Correspondence of Chancellor Leo Sapieha and Archbishop Josaphat Kuntsevich]. Minsk: Bratstvo v chest svyatogo Arkhistratiga Mikhaila v g. Minske Minskoy yeparkhii Belorusskoy Pravoslavnoy Tserkvi. [In Russian].
19. Bautovitch, M. (ed.). (2006). Epіstalyatsyya Svyatoga Yazafata: Zbor dakumentaў [Epistemology of SviatogYazafat: Collection of Notes]. Polatsak: Greka-katalіtskaya parafіya Svyatapakutnіka Yazafata. [In Belarusian].
20. Kulczynski, I. (1771). Menologium Bazylianskie, to iest żywoty śwętych pańskich oboiey płci z zakony Ś. Bazylego W. : na miesiące rozłozone i na dwie części podzielone. Cz. 2 : Drugie sześc miesięcy, to iest: lipiec, sierpień, wrzesień, pazdziernik, listopad i grudzień. Wilna. [In Polish].
21. Susza, J. (1865). Cursus Vitae et certamen martyrii B. Josaphat Cuncevicii. Parisiis. [In Polish].
22. Szymanski, P. (1862). Dokumenta do dzieów błagosławionego Józefata Kunzewicza. Przeglad Poznanski [Poznan Review], 34, 36–42. [In Polish].
23. Welykyj, A. G. (1951). S. Josaphat — Hieromartyr. Dokumenta Romana Beatificationis et Canonisationis. Analecta OSBM. Series 2, Sectio 3. (Vol. 1). Romae. [In Polish].
24. Welykyj, A. G. S. (1955). Josaphat — Hieromartyr. Dokumenta Romana Beatificationis et Canonisationis. Analecta OSBM. Series 2, Sectio 3. (Vol. 2). Romae. [In Polish].
25. Welykyj, A. G. (ed.) (1970). Documenta Unionis Berestensis ejusque auctorum. Analecta OBSM. Series 2, Sectio 3. Romae. [In Polish].
Review
For citations:
Khoteev A.S. A Few Strokes to the spiritual Portrait Hints of Uniate Archbishop Josaphat Kuntsevych. Orthodoxia. 2021;(2):97-118. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.53822/2712-9276-2021-2-97-118
Views:
836
Email this article 