Theological and Historical Aspects of the Epistolary Legacy of Schema-hegumen Ioann (Alekseev), St. Ioann of Valaam, the Valaam Elder

The article introduces the personality and epistolary legacy of Schema-hegumen Ioann (Alekseev), who pursued asceticism at the Valaam Monastery of the Transfiguration of the Saviour from 1901 to 1958. After the revolution, the territory on which the monastery stood became part of independent Finland. Consequently, the Elder spent most of his life detached from his homeland. During the Winter War of 1939–1940 between the Soviet Union and Finland, the brotherhood was evacuated deep into Finland, where they founded the New Valaam Monastery. From 1945 to 1957, the monastery was under dual jurisdiction: administratively, it was under the Finnish Church Administration, while canonically, it belonged to the Moscow Patriarchate. Since 1938, Schema- hegumen Ioann had been fulfilling the duties of the spiritual father of the monastery, giving guidance to Russian-speaking pilgrims. At the New Valaam Monastery, the ascetic became widely known as an experienced spiritual mentor. His spiritual disciples included priests, laypeople, former members of the Imperial Court, representatives of the artistic community, and ordinary individuals. Many of them received spiritual guidance from him through correspondence, which was eventually published In 1956, a collection of his letters in Russian was released at New Valaam. From 1961 to 1963, the letters were published in the émigré journal L’Eternel (The Eternal) in France. In the USSR, the Elder’s letters became known in 1958 in samizdat (underground press) format, reproduced using typewriters. In 1985, a portion of the letters was presented in the “Journal of the Moscow Patriarchate”. The collection has been reprinted multiple times and translated into other languages. In Russia, starting from 2000, the Valaam Elder’s letters have been published almost every year, becoming a kind of “handbook for the modern Christian”. Schema-hegumen Ioann did not aim to construct a logically refined theological system; his service was focused on caring for those in spiritual need. When expounding on fundamental doctrines, he relied on the Gospel and the teaching of the Fathers of the Church. His theology was not an intellectual discipline or a theory of the world’s order but an experiential communion with God, rooted in personal transformation experience. In his letters, he sometimes touched upon the issues of the contemporary church life and politics. The article highlights and analyzes the principal theological and historical aspects of the epistolary legacy of the Valaam ascetic.

1. “Molitva — glavnoe delo v dukhovnoi zhizni…”: Valaamskii starets skhiigumen Ioann (Alekseev). Zhizneopisanie, vospominaniia, pis’ma [“Prayer is the Main Thing in Spiritual Life...”: Valaam Elder Schema-hegumen Ioann (Alekseev). Biography, Memories, Letters]. (2015). Comp. by T. I. Shevchenko. Moscow: PKPTs Svet Valaama; Probel-2000. [In Russian].

2. Christ in Our Midst: Letters from a Russian Monk. (1980). New York: St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press. [In English].

3. Dergachev, S. M., archpriest. (2021). Nravstvennye imperativy dukhovnogo chteniia [Moral Imperatives of Spiritual Reading]. In E. V. Safronova (Ed.), Nravstvennye imperativy v prave, obrazovanii, nauke i kul’ture: sb. materialov IX mezhd. molodezhnogo foruma 21 maia 2021 g. [Moral Imperatives in Law, Education, Science and Culture: Collection of Writings of IX Int. Youth Forum May 21, 2021] (pp. 119–130). Belgorod: BelGU: NIU “BelGU”. [In Russian].

4. Ianson, M. A. (1994). Valaamskie startsy [Valaam Elders]. Moscow: Valaamskii monastyr’. [In Russian].

5. Ioann (Alekseev), schema-hegumen. (1956). Pis’ma Valaamskogo startsa: 1939–1956 gg. [Letters of the Valaam Elder: 1939–1956]. New Valaam. [In Russian].

6. Ioann (Alekseev), schema-hegumen. (1984). Pis’ma Valaamskogo startsa [Letters of the Valaam Elder]. Helsinki: O-vo “Druz’ia Valaama”. [In Russian].

7. Ioann (Alekseev), schema-hegumen. (1985). O molitve i dukhovnoi zhizni mirian [On Prayer and the Spiritual Life of the Laity]. Zhurnal Moskovskoi Patriarkhii, 9, 31–34. [In Russian].

8. Ioann (Alekseev), schema-hegumen. (1991). Pis’ma startsa [Letters of an Elder]. Sever, 9, 89–93. [In Russian].

9. Ioann (Alekseev), schema-hegumen. (1991). Pis’ma Valaamskogo startsa [Letters of the Valaam Elder]. Moscow. [In Russian].

10. Ioann (Alekseev), schema-hegumen. (1991). Sovety Valaamskogo startsa [Advice from the Valaam Elder]. Riga. [In Russian].

11. Ioann (Alekseev), schema-hegumen. (2003). “Zagliani v svoe serdtse”: Zhizneopisanie. Pis’ma Valaamskogo startsa [“Look into Your Heart”: Biography. Letters of the Valaam Elder]. Comp. by Onufrii (Makhanov), hierodeacon. Moscow: Izd-vo im. Svt. Ignatiia Stavropol’skogo; Prikhod khrama Sv. Dukha soshestviia. [In Russian].

12. Ioann (Alekseev), schema-hegumen. (2007). Zhizneopisanie. Pis’ma Valaamskogo startsa [Biography. Letters of the Valaam Elder]. Moscow: Izd-vo OOO “Forma T”. [In Russian].

13. Ioann (Alekseev), schema-hegumen. (2014). Pis’ma o dukhovnoi zhizni [Letters on Spiritual Life]. Comp. by V. Degterev. Sergiev Posad: Sviato-Troitskaia Sergieva lavra. [In Russian].

14. Kolliander, Sergy, archpriest. (2020). O prichislenii dvukh podvizhnikov very i blagochestiia s imenem “Ioann” k liku sviatykh Finliandskoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi: pr. Ioann Valaamskii (†1958) i mch. i isp. Ioann iz Ilomantsi (†1918) [On the Canonization of Two Ascetics of Faith and Piety with the Name “Ioann” as Saints of the Finnish Orthodox Church: St. Ioann of Valaam (†1958) and Martyr and Confessor Ioann of Ilomantsi (†1918)]. In VII Valaamskie obrazovatel’nye chteniia ““Bogoizbrannaia obitel”: k 30-letiiu vozrozhdeniia monasheskoi zhizni na Valaame”: mat-ly mezhd. konf. 17–19 maia 2019 g. Valaam [VII Valaam Educational Readings “God’s Chosen Monastery: On the 30th Anniversary of the Revival of Monastic Life on Valaam”: Materials of Intern. Conf. May 17–19, 2019, Valaam] (pp. 219–232). Moscow: PKPTs Svet Valaama; “Pero”. [In Russian].

15. Kolliander, Sergy, priest. (2015). Monakhi Starogo Valaama — sputniki moei zhizni [The Monks of Old Valaam are the Companions of My Life]. In T. I. Shevchenko (Ed.) “Molitva — glavnoe delo v dukhovnoi zhizni”: Valaamskii starets skhiigumen Ioann (Alekseev) [“Prayer is the Main Thing in Spiritual Life”: Valaam Elder Schema-hegumen Ioann (Alekseev)] (pp. 75–84). Moscow: PKPTs Svet Valaama, Probel-2000. [In Russian].

16. Ludishchev, D. V. (2017). Epitim’ia v pastyrskoi praktike [Penance in Pastoral Practice]. Sretensky sbornik, 7–8, 71–124. [In Russian].

17. Nositeli dukha sviatitelia Ignatiia: iz nastavlenii igumena Nikona (Vorob’eva), skhiigumena Ioanna (Alekseeva), igumenii Arsenii (Serebriakovoi), skhimonakhini Ardaliony (Ignatovoi) [Bearers of the Spirit of St. Ignatius: From the Instructions of Hegumen Nikon (Vorobyov), Schema-hegumen Ioann (Alekseev), Abbess Arsenia (Serebryakova), Schema-Nun Ardaliona (Ignatova)] (2009). Comp. by Ignatii (Dushein), hegumen, A. I. Osipov. Moscow: “Forma T”. [In Russian].

18. Nositeli dukha: nastavleniia o dukhovnoi zhizni [Bearers of the Spirit: Instructions on Spiritual Life] (2011). Comp. by Ignatii (Dushein), hegumen, A. I. Osipov. Moscow: Izd-vo Sretenskogo monastyria. [In Russian].

19. Panteleimon (Sarkho), archimandrite. (1992). Otets Ioann: zhizn’ Valaamskogo startsa (1873–1958) [Father Ioann: The Life of the Valaam Elder (1873–1958)]. Saint Petersburg: MGP “Polikom”. [In Russian].

20. Proskuriakov, A. Iu. (2014). Valaamskii starets, skhiigumen Ioann i ego epistoliarnoe nasledie [Valaam Elder, Schema-hegumen Ioann and His Epistolary Heritage]. Vestnik Orenburgskoi dukhovnoi seminarii, 2(2), 183–187. [In Russian].

21. Shmelev, I. S. (2011). Staryi Valaam [Old Valaam]. Moscow: Obraz. [In Russian].

22. Shor, T. (2011). “O, divnyi ostrov Valaam!”: palomnichestvo na Valaam v russkoi literature i publitsistike Estonii v 1930-e gg. [“Oh, Wonderful Island of Valaam!”: Pilgrimage to Valaam in Russian Literature and Estonian Journalism in the 1930s]. In Studia Russica Helsingiensia et Tartuensia XII: Mifologiia kul’turnogo prostranstva: K 80-letiiu Sergeia Gennadievicha Isakova [Studia Russica Helsingiensia et Tartuensia XII: Mythology of Cultural Space: To the 80th Anniversary of Sergei Gennadievich Isakov] (pp. 121–145). Tartu: Tartu Ülikooli Kirjastus. [In Russian].

23. Smolina, A. N. (2018). Rechevoi zhanr uteshenie v epistoliarnom tserkovno-religioznom obshchenii (na materiale pisem russkikh tserkovnykh pisatelei-monakhov XX veka) [Speech Genre of Consolation in Epistolary Church-Religious Communication (Based on the Letters of Russian Church Writers-Monks of the 20th Century)]. Nauka o cheloveke: gumanitarnye issledovaniia, 32(2), 36–42. [In Russian].

24. Smolina, A. N. (2019). Isikhastskaia ideia obozheniia i ee reprezentatsiia v dukhovnom epistoliarii russkogo pravoslavnogo monashestva XX v. [The Hesychast Idea of Deification and Its Representation in the Spiritual Epistolary of Russian Orthodox Monasticism of the 20th Century]. Nauchnyi dialog, 5, 139–153. [In Russian].

25. Smolina, A. N. (2021). Dukhovnyi epistoliarii russkogo pravoslavnogo monashestva XX — nachala XXI v.: tipologiia zhanrovykh form, ikh ritoriko-stilisticheskaia organizatsiia, rechevoi etiket: avtoref. dis. ... kand. filol. nauk [Spiritual Epistolary of Russian Orthodox Monasticism of the 20th — Early 21st Centuries: Typology of Genre Forms, Their Rhetorical and Stylistic Organization, Speech Etiquette] [Author’s Abstract of Dissertation of Candidate of Philological Sciences]. Krasnoyarsk. [In Russian].

26. Smolina, A. N. (2022). Intertekstual’nye vkliucheniia v russkoi dukhovnoi epistoliarnoi kommunikatsii: tipologiia, funktsii, kontekst [Intertextual Inclusions in Russian Spiritual Epistolary Communication: Typology, Functions, Context]. Nauchnyi dialog, 11(2), 122–139. [In Russian].

27. Soini, E. G. (2017). Vzaimoproniknovenie russkoi i finskoi literatury v pervoi polovine XX v. [Interpenetration of Russian and Finnish Literature in the First Half of the 20th Century]. Moscow: Izdatel’sky dom IaSK. [In Russian].

28. Tretyakov, S. V. (2010). Podvizhnik Spaso-Preobrazhenskogo Valaamskogo monastyria skhiigumen Ioann (Alekseev) i ego dukhovnoe nasledie [The Ascetic of the Spaso-Preobrazhensky Valaam Monastery, Schema-hegumen Ioann (Alekseev) and His Spiritual Heritage]. Pravoslavnyi khristianin, 2, 21–28. [In Russian].