Gennady Shimanov and His Unfulfilled Dream of “Orthodoxizing the Soviet State”

The article delves into the life and endeavors of Gennady Mikhailovich Shimanov (1937–2014), a relatively unknown to the wide audience yet a profoundly intriguing thinker, Orthodox publicist and dissident of the Soviet and post‑Soviet eras. It provides an overview of his biography and creative journey, highlighting his atypical position within the dissident and human rights movement, which predominantly leaned towards liberalism. In general, Shimanov’s beliefs revolved around practicing Orthodoxy during the Soviet era, Christian socialism, and Russian nationalism. The article focuses on Shimanov’s historiosophical prediction in the 1970s, suggesting the transformation of the Soviet state into an Orthodox theocracy, and the subsequent debates within the dissident literature of that time. Unusual for that period was Shimanov’s conviction in the necessity of maintaining loyalty to the Soviet state even on the part of dissidents. The article also touches upon Shimanov’s post‑Soviet creative works and their character, notably after the collapse of the USSR when his expectations starkly failed to fulfill, or fulfilled in the opposite direction. Nevertheless, other successful ideas and predictions by Shimanov are acknowledged. For example, those regarding the detrimental consequences that the country and society would experience if the liberal approach was chosen as the way out of the historical impasse of the Soviet era. The article also notes weaknesses in Shimanov’s ideologies, particularly evident in the post‑Soviet years: painful antisemitism, excessive social interpretation in understanding of Christianity, and ideological engagement. Simultaneously, the article acknowledges positive aspects of his ideas, namely his focus on national and family issues that heavily impacted the future of the Russian people.

1. Bibikhin, V. V. (2003). Dlia sluzhebnogo pol’zovaniia [For Official Use]. In Drugoe nachalo [Another Beginning] (pp. 181–208). Saint Petersburg : Nauka. [In Russian].

2. Ianov, A. (1978). Ideal’noe gosudarstvo Gennadiia Shimanova [The Ideal State of Gennady Shimanov]. Sintaksis, 1, 31–56. [In Russian].

3. Mikhailovsky, A. V., Stoeckl, K. (2021). Interv’iu s Sergeem Khoruzhim ob istorii i sovremennom sostoianii otechestvennoi religioznoi mysli Filosofiia [Interview with Sergei Khoruzhim About the History and Current State of Domestic Religious Thought]. Zhurnal Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki, 5 (1), 169–181. [In Russian].

4. Predislovie [Preface]. (2013). In G.M. Shimanov Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 5–11). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

5. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Dva usloviia deistvitel’nogo vozrozhdeniia khristianstva v Rossii [Two Conditions for the Real Revival of Christianity in Russia]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 842–865). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

6. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Ideal’noe gosudarstvo [Ideal State]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 217–232). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

7. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Izbytok sobstvennosti op’ianiaet um cheloveka [Excess Property Intoxicates the Human Mind]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 536–548). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

8. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Kak otnosit’sia k sovetskoi vlasti [How to Relate to Soviet Power]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 192–208). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

9. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Kak ponimat’ nashu istoriiu [How to Understand Our History]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 178–192). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

10. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Moskva — Tretii Rim [Moscow is the Third Rome]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 208–215). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

11. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Nel’zia pobedit’ Kashcheevo tsarstvo, ne imeia zdravoi emu al’ternativy [It is Impossible to Defeat the Kashcheevo Kingdom Without Having a Sound Alternative]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 635–651). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

12. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Nuzhna dvustoronniaia sosredotochennost’ cheloveka [A Person Needs Two-Sided Concentration]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 826–832). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

13. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Otryvki iz dnevnika [Excerpts from the Diary]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 139–148). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

14. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Pered smert’iu. Samizdatovskii sbornik 1969 g. [Before Death. Samizdat Collection of 1969]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 12–113). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

15. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Psevdodemokraticheskoe pravosoznanie [Pseudo-democratic Legal Consciousness]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 372–389). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

16. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Put’ zhizni [The Path of Life]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 166–170). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

17. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Tema dlia razmyshlenii [Topic for Reflection]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 392–405). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

18. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Tri otkrytykh pis’ma N. A. Struve. Pis’mo pervoe [Three Open Letters to N. A. Struve. First Letter]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 118–126). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

19. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). U nashei tserkvi net svoego sotsial’nogo ucheniia [Our Church Does Not Have Its Own Social Teaching]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 525–536). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

20. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Zasluga N. V. Somina [Merit of N. V. Somin]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 626–635). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

21. Shimanov, G.M. (2013). Zdorovaia sem’ia kak uslovie natsional’noi bezopasnosti Rossii [A Healthy Family as a Condition for the National Security of Russia]. In Zapiski iz krasnogo doma [Notes from the Red House] (pp. 886–895). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

22. Shimanov, G.M. (2016). Chto takoe istoriia i zachem ona nuzhna Bogu i liudiam [What History is and Why Does God and People Need It]. In V. Iu. Katasonov, V. N. Trostnikov, G.M. Shimanov Istoriia kak Promysl Bozhii [History as God’s Providence] (pp. 610–625). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii, Izdatel’skii dom “Kislorod”. [In Russian].

23. Sinyavsky, A. D. (2001). Osnovy sovetskoi tsivilizatsii [Fundamentals of Soviet Civilization]. Moscow: Agraf. [In Russian].

24. Suslov, M.M. (2006). Utopichesky proekt G.M. Shimanova v kontekste pravogo dissidentskogo dvizheniia v SSSR v 1960–1980-kh gg. [Utopian Project of G.M. Shimanov in the Context of the Right-Wing Dissident Movement in the USSR in the 1960–1980s]. In V mire konservatizma: idei, praktika, liudi. Mezhvuzovskii sbornik nauchnykh trudov [In the World of Conservatism: Ideas, Practice, People. Interuniversity Collection of Scientific Papers] (pp. 174–198). Perm: PGU. [In Russian].