Protective and Conservative Tendencies in the Life and Works of the Priest Pavel Florensky

The  article  discusses   an  important feature  of  Pavel Florensky’s biography and legacy that  has not been properly covered by the existing research.  Florensky is a well-known religious philosopher,  the  author  of The Pillar and  Ground  of the  Truth and lectures  on the philosophy of cult and the philosophy of art. Russian theologists tend to perceive his ideas on a par with Sergei Bulgakov’s sophiology, in line with the modernizing trends  of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, which are characterized positively or negatively, depending on the preferences of scholars. The article identifies and comments on some basic facts that testify to Florensky’s desire to preserve intact the dogmata, the canons and the sacraments of the Orthodox  Church. It highlights Florensky’s ideas directed against the concept of progress in the religious consciousness  of mankind and the  associated theory  of “dogmatic development”. The main attention is drawn to Florensky’s position and actions during the upheavals of 1905–1907 and after the February Revolution of 1917. His efforts  to preserve the liturgical and monastic life in the Trinity Lavra of St. Sergius and other characteristic moments of his work under the Soviets are detailed. The main conclusion is that,  although Florensky’s works contain  ambiguous concepts and theologoumena, he should still be regarded as a conservative thinker who always had in mind the main goal for which the Orthodox Church existed.

1. Berdyaev, N. A. (2001). Stilizovannoe pravoslavie [Stylized Orthodoxy]. In P. A. Florensky: Pro et contra: Lichnost’ i tvorchestvo Pavla Florenskogo v otsenke russkih myslitelei i issledovatelei: Antologiia [P. A. Florensky: Pro et contra: The Personality and Work of Pavel Florensky in the Assessment of Russian Thinkers and Researchers: An Anthology] (pp. 264–282). Saint Petersburg: RKhGA. [In Russian].

2. Biriukov, D. S. (2020). “Sinergeticheskoe otkrovenie real’nosti”: Issledovaniia o predystorii, istochnikakh i soderzhanii poniatii “simvol”, “sinergiia” i “energiia” u P. A. Florenskogo v kontekste retseptsii palamizma v russkoi mysli nachala KhKh v. [“Synergetic Revelation of Reality”: Research on the Background, Sources and Content of the Concepts of “Symbol”, “Synergy” and “Energy” by P. A. Florensky in the Context of the Reception of Palamism in Russian Thought in the Early Twentieth Century]. Voprosy filosofii, (6), 103–115. [In Russian].

3. Bonetskaia, N. K. (2003). P. Florensky: russkoe geteanstvo [Florensky: Russian Goetheanism]. Voprosy filosofii, (3), 97–116. [In Russian].

4. Florensky, P. A. (1990). Stolp i utverzhdenie istiny [The Pillar and Ground of the Truth]. In Works in 2 volumes (Vol. 1, part 1). Moscow: Pravda. [In Russian].

5. Florensky, P. A. (2018). Bogoslovskie trudy. 1902–1909 [Theological Works. 1902–1909]. Moscow: Izd-vo PSTGU. [In Russian].

6. Florensky, P., priest. (1994). Voprosy religioznogo samopoznaniia [Questions of Religious Self-Knowledge]. In Works in 4 volumes (Vol. 1, pp. 528–549). Moscow: Mysl’. [In Russian].

7. Florensky, P., priest. (1996). Khramovoe deistvo kak sintez iskusstv [Temple Action as a Synthesis of Arts]. In Izbrannye trudy po iskusstvu [Selected Works on Art] (pp. 201–215). Moscow: Izobraz. iskusstvo: Tsentr izucheniia okhrany i restavratsii naslediia sviashchennika P. Florenskogo. [In Russian].

8. Florensky, P., priest. (1996). Okolo Khomyakova [Near Khomyakov]. In Works in 4 volumes (Vol. 2, pp. 278–336). Moscow: Mysl’. [In Russian].

9. Florensky, P., priest. (1999). Works in 4 volumes (Vol. 3, part 2). Moscow: Mysl’. [In Russian].

10. Florensky, P., priest. (2004). Filosofiia kul’ta: (Opyt pravoslavnoi antropoditsei) [Philosophy of the Cult: (The Experience of Orthodox Anthropodicy)]. In Collected Works (Vol. 2). Moscow: Mysl’. [In Russian].

11. Florensky, P., priest. (2009). Predpolagaemoe gosudarstvennoe ustroistvo v budushchem: sb. arkhivnykh materialov i statei [Proposed State Structure in the Future: A Collection of Archival Materials and Articles]. Moscow: Izdatel’skii dom “Gorodets”. [In Russian].

12. Fudel’, S. I. (2001). Ob o. Pavle Florenskom [About Father Pavel Florensky]. In P. A. Florensky: Pro et contra: Lichnost’ i tvorchestvo Pavla Florenskogo v otsenke russkih myslitelei i issledovatelei: Antologiia [P. A. Florensky: Pro et contra: The Personality and Work of Pavel Florensky in the Assessment of Russian Thinkers and Researchers: An Anthology] (pp. 49–140). Saint Petersburg: RKhGA. [In Russian].

13. Gavriushin, N. K. (2005). Russkoe bogoslovie. Ocherki i portrety [Russian Theology. Essays and Portraits]. Nizhny Novgorod: Glagol. [In Russian].

14. Ivanova, E. V. (2004). Pavel Florensky i simvolisty. Opyty literaturnye. Stat’i. Perepiska [Pavel Florensky and the Symbolists. Literary Experiences. Articles. Correspondence]. Moscow: Iazyki slavianskoi kul’tury. [In Russian].

15. Pavliuchenkov, N. N. (2015). Ideia Sofii v trudakh sviashchennika Pavla Florenskogo [The Idea of Sophia in the Writings of the Priest Pavel Florensky]. Vestnik Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriia I: Bogoslovie. Filosofiia, 60(4), 24–38. [In Russian].

16. Pavliuchenkov, N. N. (2019). Liturgicheskoe bogoslovie v lektsiiakh po “Filosofii kul’ta” sviashchennika Pavla Florenskogo: osnovnye osobennosti i istochniki [Liturgical Theology in Lectures on the “Philosophy of Cult” by Priest Pavel Florensky: Main Features and Sources]. Russko-Vizantiiskii vestnik, 2(1), 78–103. [In Russian].

17. Perepiska P. A. Florenskogo i V. F. Erna [Correspondence of P. A. Florensky with V. F. Ern] (2014). In Russkoe bogoslovie: issledovaniia i materialy [Russian Theology: Research and Materials] (pp. 199–231). Moscow: PSTGU. [In Russian].

18. Perepiska sviashch. P. A. Florenskogo s M. A. Novoselovym [Correspondence of Priest P. A. Florensky with M. A. Novoselov]. (1999). Tomsk: Vodolei. [In Russian].

19. Perepiska sviashch. P. A. Florenskogo so sviashch. S. N. Bulgakovym [Correspondence of Priest P. A. Florensky with Priest S. N. Bulgakov]. (2001). Tomsk: Vodolei. [In Russian].

20. Rozanov, V. V. (2010). Perepiska V. V. Rozanova i P. A. Florenskogo [Correspondence of V. V. Rozanov with P. A. Florensky]. In Literaturnye izgnanniki. Kniga vtoraia [Literary Exiles. Second Book] (pp. 9–412). Moscow: “Respublika”; Saint Petersburg: “Rostok”. [In Russian].

21. S. N. Bulgakov: Pro et contra: Lichnost’ i tvorchestvo Bulgakova v otsenke russkih myslitelei i issledovatelei: antologiia: v 2. t. [S. N. Bulgakov: Pro et contra: The Personality and Work of Bulgakov in the Assessment of Russian Thinkers and Researchers: An Anthology: In 2 volumes]. (2003). (Vol. 1). Saint Petersburg: RKhGA. [In Russian].

22. Sobolev, Serafim, archbishop. (1935). Novoe uchenie o Sofii Premudrosti Bozhiei [New Teaching on Sophia, the Wisdom of God]. Sofia. [In Russian].

23. Trubachev, Andronik, abbot. (1987). Sviashchennik Pavel Florenskii — professor Moskovskoi dukhovnoi akademii i redaktor “Bogoslovskogo vestnika” [Priest Pavel Florensky — professor at the Moscow Theological Academy and Editor of “The Theological Bulletin”]. In Bogoslovskie trudy. Sb. 28 [Theological Works] (Vol. 28, pp. 290–314). Moscow: Izd-vo Moskovskoi Patriarkhii. [In Russian].

24. Trubachev, Andronik, abbot. (2015). Bibliograficheskii spravochnik. Lichnost’, zhizn’ i tvorchestvo sviashchennika Pavla Florenskogo [Bibliographic Reference Book. Personality, Life and Work of the Priest Pavel Florensky]. Sergiev Posad: Fond nauki i pravoslavnoi kul’tury sviashchennika Pavla Florenskogo. [In Russian].

25. Trubachev, S. Z. (2006). Sergiev Posad v zhizni Pavla Florenskogo [Sergiev Posad in the Life of Pavel Florensky]. Nyne i prisno, (3–4), 91–128. [In Russian].

26. Volkov, S. A. (2001). P. A. Florensky. In P. A. Florenskii: Pro et contra: Lichnost’ i tvorchestvo Pavla Florenskogo v otsenke russkih myslitelei i issledovatelei: Antologiia [P. A. Florensky: Pro et contra: The Personality and Work of Pavel Florensky in the Assessment of Russian Thinkers and Researchers: An Anthology] (pp. 141–161). Saint Petersburg: RKhGA. [In Russian].

27. Vvedensky, A. I. (1904). K voprosu o metodologicheskoi reforme pravoslavnoi dogmatiki [On the Question of the Methodological Reform of Orthodox Dogmatics]. Bogoslovskii vestnik, (6), 179–209. [In Russian].

28. Zhevakhov, N. D., prince. (1993). September 1915 — March 1917. In Memories in 2 volumes (Vol. 1). Saint Petersburg: Rodnik. [In Russian].