Russian Conservatism in the First Quarter of the 19th Century

The article examines the features of the Russian conservatism in the period of its emergence in the fi rst quarter of the 19th century. The specifi c character of the Russian conservatism lay in the fact that it had been conceived as a reaction to the radical westernization. The manifestations and main symbols of this process in the 17th — early 19th centuries included the reforms of Peter The Great and the extreme (for the time) liberalism of Alexander I, which had provoked the opposition on the part of the conservative-minded nobility. The project of constitutional reforms associated with in the name of M. M. Speransky was of particular importance. The list also included Gallomania, the form of Westernism among the Russian nobility; Napoleonic aggression against the Russian Empire, the Treaty of Tilsit 1807 and the Patriotic War of 1812, as well as an attempt to create a so-called “all-Christian state” in the spirit of the declarations of the Holy Alliance, which from 1817 to 1824 had actually served to deprive the Orthodox Church of the dominant status. Not without reason, Russian conservatives perceived these phenomena and events as a threat that might lead to the destruction of all the fundamental foundations of the traditional society: autocratic power, the Orthodox Church and religion, the Russian language, national traditions, class society boundaries, patriarchal life, etc. The unprecedented nature of the challenge generated a conservative response designed to protect the fundamental traditional values. The main axioms of the emerging Russian conservatism were formulated as a result of confl icts with representatives of the Russian liberal Westernism. These deemed the imitation of revolutionary and liberal Western European models inadmissible, and proclaimed the need to rely on one’s own traditions (linguistic, religious, political, cultural, domestic) and such values as patriotism, including the cultivation of national feelings and devotion to the autocratic monarchy. Having blocked the constitutional project by M. M. Speransky, conservatives played a huge role as ideologists and military statesmen in the events of 1812–1814, had a signifi cant impact on the formation of the university education system, and actually achieved the rejection of the ecumenical experiment in 1824, which would de facto deprive the Orthodox Church of its dominant status. During the struggle of the “Orthodox opposition” against Western European mysticism and Freemasonry, the system of Orthodox values had a signifi cant impact on the formation of the Russian conservatism. The greatest role in the formation and development of the Russian conservatism in the fi rst quarter of the 19th century was played by such fi gures as A. S. Shishkov, F. V. Rostopchin, Grand Duchess Ekaterina Pavlovna, A. А. Arakcheev, M. L. Magnitsky, A. S. Sturdza and Archimandrite Photius (Spassky). The central fi gure of the Russian conservatism was N.M. Karamzin.

1. Altshuller, M. (2007). Beseda liubitelei russkogo slova. U istokov russkogo slavianofil’stva [Conversation of Lovers of the Russian Word. At the Origins of Russian Slavophilism]. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. [In Russian].

2. Degtyareva, M. I. (2007). Zhozef de Mestr i ego russkie sobesedniki. Opyt filosofskoi biografii i intellektual’nye sviazi v Rossii [Joseph de Maistre and His Russian Interlocutors. The Experience of Philosophical Biography and Intellectual Connections in Russia]. Perm: Aster. [In Russian].

3. Dnevnik V. K. Kiukhel’bekera. Materialy k istorii russkoi literaturnoi i obshchestvennoi zhizni 10–40 godov XIX veka [Diary of V. K. Kuchelbecker. Materials for the History of Russian Literary and Social Life of the 10–40 Years of the XIX Century]. (1929). Leningrad: Priboi. [In Russian].

4. Ermashov, D. V., Shirinyants, A. A. (1999). U istokov rossiiskogo konservatizma: N. M. Karamzin [At the Origins of Russian Conservatism: N. M. Karamzin]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo universiteta. [In Russian].

5. Gornostaev, M. V. (2005). Fedor Vasil’evich Rostopchin [Fedor Vasilyevich Rostopchin]. In Protiv techeniia: istoricheskie portrety russkikh konservatorov pervoi treti XIX stoletiia (chapter 3, pp. 113–141). Voronezh: Voronezhskiy gosudarstvennyi universitet. [In Russian].

6. Gusev, V. A. (2001). Russkii konservatizm: osnovnye napravleniia i etapy razvitiia [Russian Conservatism: the Main Directions and Stages of Development]. Tver: Tverskoi gosudarstvennyi universitet. [In Russian].

7. Jena, D. (2006). Ekaterina Pavlovna. Velikaia kniazhna, koroleva Viurtemberga [Grand Duchess, Queen of Wu¨rttemberg]. Moscow: AST. [In Russian].

8. Kitaev, V. A. (2005). N. M. Karamzin [N. M. Karamzin]. In Protiv techeniia: istoricheskie portrety russkikh konservatorov pervoi treti XIX stoletiia (pp. 171–195). Voronezh: Voronezhskii gosudarstvennyi universitet. [In Russian].

9. Kniaz’ Aleksandr Nikolaevich Golitsyn — predstavitel’ mistiko-kosmopoliticheskogo konservatizma v tsarstvovanie Aleksandra I [Prince Alexander Nikolaevich Golitsyn — a Representative of Mystical and Cosmopolitan Conservatism in the Reign of Alexander I]. (2010). Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ser. Lingvistika i mezhkul’turnaia kommunikatsiia, (1), 186–189. [In Russian].

10. Kondakov, Yu. E. (1998). Dukhovno-religioznaia politika Aleksandra I i russkaia pravoslavnaia oppozitsiia (1801–1825) [The Spiritual and Religious Policy of Alexander I and the Russian Orthodox Opposition (1801–1825)]. St. Petersburg: Nestor. [In Russian].

11. Kondakov, Yu. E. (2000). Arkhimandrit Foty (1792–1838) i ego vremia [Archimandrite Photius (1792–1838) and His Time]. St. Petersburg: Rossiiskaia natsional’naia biblioteka. [In Russian].

12. Kondakov, Yu. E. (2014). Kniaz’ A. N. Golitsyn: pridvornyi, chinovnik, khristianin: monografiia [Prince A. N. Golitsyn: Courtier, Official, Christian: Monograph]. St. Petersburg: ElekSis. [In Russian].

13. Lupareva, N. N. (2012). “Otechestvoliubets”: obshchestvenno-politicheskaia deiatel’nost’ i vzgliady Sergeia Nikolaevicha Glinki [“Fatherland Lover”: Socio-Political Activity and Views of Sergei Nikolaevich Glinka]. Voronezh: Novyi vzgliad. [In Russian].

14. Meshcheryakova, A. O. (2007). F. V. Rostopchin: u osnovaniia koservatizma i natsionalizma v Rossii [F. V. Rostopchin: at the Foundation of Conservatism and Nationalism in Russia]. Voronezh: Kitezh. [In Russian].

15. Minakov, A. Y. (2016). A. S. Sturdza: intellektual’naia biografiia pravoslavnogo myslitelia [A. S. Sturdza: Intellectual Biography of an Orthodox Thinker]. Khristianskoe chtenie, (1), 176–194. [In Russian].

16. Minakov, A. Y. (2020). Istoriia russkogo konservatizma XIX–XXI vv. [History of Russian Conservatism of the XIX–XXI Centuries]. Voronezh: Izdatel’skii dom VGU. [In Russian].

17. Minakov, A. Y. (2021). M. L. Magnitskii. Iz istorii stanovleniia russkogo konservatizma pervoi chetverti XIX veka. [M. L. Magnitsky. From the History of the Formation of Russian Conservatism in the First Quarter of the XIX Century]. Voronezh: Izdatel’sky dom VGU. [In Russian].

18. Minakov, A. Yu. (2010). Mikhail Leontievich Magnitsky [Mikhail Leontievich Magnitsky]. Voprosy istorii, (11), 36–49. [In Russian].

19. Minakov, A. Yu. (2002). Frankobesie [Frankobesie]. Rodina, (8), 18–19. [In Russian].

20. Minakov, A. Yu. (2002а ). “Rassuzhdenie o starom i novom sloge rossiiskogo iazyka” A. S. Shishkova — pervyi manifest russkogo konservativnogo natsionalizma [“Reasoning about the Old and New Syllable of the Russian Language” A. S. Shishkov — the First Manifesto of Russian Conservative Nationalism]. In Problemy etnicheskoi istorii Tsentral’noi, Vostochnoi i Iugo-Vostochnoi Evropy v novoe i noveishee vremia: Sb. nauchn. trudov. Vyp. 1 (pp. 239–253). Voronezh: Voronezhsky gosudarstvennyi universitet. [In Russian].

21. Minakov, A. Yu. (2004). Opyt tipologii techenii v rannem russkom konservatizme pervoi chetverti XIX veka [Experience of Typology of Trends in Early Russian Conservatism of the First Quarter of the XIX Century]. In Rossiiskaia imperiia: strategii stabilizatsii i opyty obnovleniia (pp. 267–280). Voronezh: Izdatel’stvo Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. [In Russian].

22. Minakov, A. Yu. (2005). Rol’ sobyty 1812 g. v stanovlenii russkogo konservatizma [The Role of the Events of 1812 in the Formation of Russian Conservatism]. In Konservatizm v Rossii i Zapadnoi Evrope (pp. 7–17). Voronezh: Izdatel’stvo Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. [In Russian].

23. Minakov, A. Yu. (2009). Vozniknovenie russkogo konservativnogo natsionalizma v pervoi chetverti XIX v. v Rossii [The Emergence of Russian Conservative Nationalism in the First Quarter of the XIX Century in Russia]. Vestnik Rossiiskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im. Immanuila Kanta. Vyp. 12: Ser. Gumanitarnye nauki, (12), 12–17. [In Russian].

24. Minakov, A. Yu. (2010). “Tverskaia poluboginia”: velikaia kniaginia Ekaterina Pavlovna — lider konservativnoi natsional’no-aristokraticheskoi “partii” [“Tver Demigodess”: Grand Duchess Ekaterina Pavlovna — Leader of the Conservative National-Aristocratic “Party”]. Rossiia XXI, (4), 102–123. [In Russian].

25. Minakov, A. Yu. (2011). Russky konservatizm v pervoi chetverti XIX v. [Russian Conservatism in the First Quarter of the XIX Century]. Voronezh: Izd-vo Voronezh. gos. un-ta. [In Russian].

26. Minakov, A. Yu. (2011а ). Predislovie [Preface]. In Shishkov A. S. Ogon’ liubvi k Otechestvu (pp. 5–22). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

27. Minakov, A. Yu. (2013). A. A. Arakcheev — lider konservativnoi “russkoi partii” v 1820-e gg. [A. A. Arakcheev — Leader of the Conservative “Russian Party” in the 1820s]. Vestnik Surgutskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta, (25), 5–17. [In Russian].

28. Minakov, A. Yu. (2013). Predislovie [Preface]. In Karamzin N. M. O liubvi k Otechestvu i narodnoi gordosti (pp. 5–58). Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii. [In Russian].

29. Minakov, A. Yu. (2015). Kniaz’-inok Anikita (Sergei Aleksandrovich Shirinskii-Shikhmatov): put’ iz poetov v sviatye [Prince-Monk Anikita (Sergey Aleksandrovich Shirinsky-Shikhmatov): the Path from Poets to Saints]. Khristianskoe chtenie, (4), 105–120. [In Russian].

30. Minakov, A. Yu., Repnikov, A. V., Chernavsky, M. Yu. (2005). Konservatizm [Conservatism]. In Obshchestvennaia mysl’ Rossii XVIII — nachala XX veka: Entsiklopediia (pp. 217–220). Moscow: ROSSPEN. [In Russian].

31. Nazarenko, E. Yu. (2014). Kniaz’ A. N. Golitsyn v obshchestvennopoliticheskoi i religioznoi istorii Rossii pervoi poloviny XIX veka: monografiia [Prince A. N. Golitsyn in the Socio-Political and Religious History of Russia in the First Half of the XIX Century: Monograph]. Voronezh: Izdatel’sky dom VGU. [In Russian].

32. Nikolai Mikhailovich (Romanov). (1912). Imperator Aleksandr I [Emperor Alexander I] (Vol. 1). St. Petersburg: Ekspeditsiia zagotovleniia gosudarstvennykh bumag. [In Russian].

33. Parsamov, V. S. (2010). Alexander Semyonovich Shishkov [Alexander Semyonovich Shishkov]. In Shishkov A. S. Izbrannye Trudy (pp. 5–68). Moscow: ROSSPEN. [In Russian].

34. Repnikov, A. V. (2014). Konservativnye modeli rossiiskoi gosudarstvennosti [Conservative Models of Russian Statehood]. Moscow: ROSSPEN. [In Russian].

35. Russkii konservatizm serediny XVIII — nachala XX veka: entsiklopediia [Russian Conservatism of the Middle of the XVIII — Early XX Century: Encyclopedia]. (2010). Moscow: ROSSPEN. [In Russian].

36. Shevchenko, M. M. (2003). Konets odnogo Velichiia. Vlast’, obrazovanie i pechatnoe slovo v Imperatorskoi Rossii na poroge Osvoboditel’nykh reform [The End of One Greatness. Power, Education and the Printed Word in Imperial Russia on the Threshold of Liberation Reforms]. Moscow: Tri kvadrata. [In Russian].

37. Shirinyants, A. A. (2015). “Konservator”: slovo i smysly v russkoi sotsial’no-politicheskoi mysli [“Conservative”: Word and Meanings in Russian Socio-Political Thought]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Ser. 12: Politicheskie nauki, (6), pp. 112–124. [In Russian].

38. Vishlenkova, E. A. (2002). Zabotias’ o dushakh poddannykh: religioznaia politika v Rossii pervoi chetverti XIX veka [Taking Care of the Souls of Subjects: Religious Policy in Russia in the First Quarter of the XIX Century]. Saratov: Izd-vo Sarat. un-ta. [In Russian].

39. Volodina, T. A. (2005). Sergei Nikolaevich Glinka [Sergey Nikolaevich Glinka]. In Protiv techeniia: istoricheskie portrety russkikh konservatorov pervoi treti XIX stoletiia (chapter 4, pp. 142–170). Voronezh: Voronezhskiy gosudarstvennyi universitet. [In Russian].

40. Yachmenikhin, K. M. (1997). Alexey Andreevich Arakcheev [Alexey Andreevich Arakcheev]. In Rossiiskie conservatory (pp. 17–62). Moscow: Informatsionno-izdatel’skoe agentstvo “Russkii mir”. [In Russian].

41. Yachmenikhin, K. M. (2004). “Arakcheevshchina”: istoriograficheskie mify [“Arakcheevschina”: Historiographical Myths]. In Konservatizm v Rossii i mire. Ch. 1. (pp. 117–128). Voronezh: Voronezhskii gosudarstvennyi universitet, 2004. [In Russian].

42. Yachmenikhin, K. M. (2005). A. A. Arakcheev [A. A. Arakcheev]. In Protiv techeniia: istoricheskie portrety russkikh konservatorov pervoi treti XIX stoletiia (pp. 196–217). Voronezh: Voronezhskii gosudarstvennyi universitet. [In Russian].

43. Zorin, A. (2001). Kormia dvuglavogo orla… Literatura i gosudarstvennaia ideologiia v Rossii v poslednei treti XVIII — pervoi treti XIX veka [Feeding the Double — Headed Eagle… Literature and State Ideology in Russia in the Last Third of the XVIII-First Third of the XIX Century]. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. [In Russian].