“The Patriarchal Authority Always Remains Present in the Church in its Entirety”: Patriarch Tikhon, Metropolitan Sergius (Stragorodsky) and the Ideas of Church Democracy

The sharp criticism expressed by opponents towards Patriarch Tikhon and Metropolitan Sergius (Stragorodsky) was not so much related to their complimentary statements towards the Soviet government (Patriarch Tikhon’s such statements have been known since 1923), but rather to their methods of governance. Opponents believed that Patriarch Tikhon and Metropolitan Sergius were dismantling the established church democracy that had emerged as a result of the Local Council of 1917–1918. In the early 20th century, such democracy was called conciliarity, which implied church representation, a system of elections from the bottom up with a periodicity of several years. The ideas of intrachurch republicanism were actively developing throughout the second half of the 19th and early 20th centuries. The system of representative church institutions established after the spiritualschool reform at the deanery and diocesan levels served as a school of democracy for the Russian clergy for half a century. Republican ideas were still strong at the Local Council of 1917–1918. They were the main basis for opposing the plans to introduce patriarchy. The ordinations of married priests to bishops without taking monastic vows by the renewalists, and then the recognition of a married episcopate at the so-called Second All-Russian Local Council of 1923, led the R.O.C. (Russian Orthodox Church) of the renewalists beyond the canonical field, which the renewalists were well aware of. Therefore, they sought to superimpose the church democratic system that had formed within their structures after the “abolition” of patriarchy in 1923 to a universal level. Together with the Greeks, the renewalists developed plans for the periodic regular holding of representative assemblies of Local Churches, which they called Universal Councils. These councils were envisaged as a radical transformation of both the canonical structure and, subsequently, the dogmatic teachings of the Orthodox Church. Thus, under favorable historical circumstances, the development of Russian church republicanism could fundamentally undermine the foundations of Universal Orthodoxy. However, patriarchal authority in post-revolutionary Russia stood in the way of these plans. Such actions by the patriarchal authority require a closer look at the perception of the Moscow metropolitan, and then the patriarch in the Russian church consciousness of the 15th-17th centuries, where the fact of repeated episcopal ordination indicates that the Head of the Church was not simply one of the bishops.

1. Akty Sviateishego Tikhona, Patriarkha Moskovskogo i vseia Rossii, pozdneishie dokumenty i perepiska o kanonicheskom preemstve vysshei tserkovnoi vlasti, 1917–1943 [Acts of His Holiness Tikhon, Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia, Later Documents and Correspondence on the Canonical Succession of the Supreme Church Authority, 1917–1943]. (1994). Moscow : Izd-vo Pravoslav. Sviato-Tikhonov. bogoslov. in-ta : Bratstvo vo imia Vsemilostivogo Spasa. [In Russian].

2. Balakshina, Iu. V. (2015). Bratstvo revnitelei tserkovnogo obnovleniia (gruppa “32-kh” peterburgskikh sviashchennikov), 1903–1907 : dokumental’naia istoriia i kul’turnyi kontekst [Brotherhood of Zealots of Church Renewal (a Group of “32” St. Petersburg Priests), 1903–1907 : Documentary History and Cultural Context]. Moscow : Sviato-Filaretovsky pravoslavno-khristiansky in-t. [In Russian].

3. Vitaly (Utkin I. N.), Hegumen. (2022). Tema Vselenskogo sobora v obnovlencheskoi pechati 20-kh godov XX veka [The Theme of the Ecumenical Council in the Renovationist Press of the 20s of the XX Century]. Vestnik Omskoi pravoslavnoi dukhovnoi seminarii, (13), 168– 173. [In Russian].

4. Vitaly (Utkin I. N.), Hegumen. (2021). Politicheskie idei i politicheskaia bor’ba dorevoliutsionnogo russkogo dukhovenstva (na primere Riazanskoi eparkhii) [Political Ideas and the Political Struggle of the Pre-Revolutionary Russian Clergy (on the Example of the Ryazan Diocese)]. Orthodoxia, (1), 125–159. [In Russian].

5. Ganelin, R. Sh. (1969). Rossiia i SShA : Ocherki istorii rus.-amerik. otnoshenii. 1914–1917 [Russia and the USA : Essays on the History of the Russian-Americas. Relationships. 1914–1917]. Leningrad : Nauka. Leningr. otd-nie. [In Russian].

6. Zheltov, M., Priest. (2010). Intronizatsiia [Enthronement]. In Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia (Vol. XXIII, pp. 124–131). Moscow : TsNTs “Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia”. [In Russian].

7. Istoriia Russkoi tserkvi. Kn. 9: 1917–1997 [The History of the Russian Church. Book 9: 1917–1997]. (1997). Moscow : Izd-vo Spaso-Preobrazh. Valaam. monastyria. [In Russian].

8. K tserkovnomu soboru : sb. [To the Church Synod : Collection]. (1906). Saint Petersburg : tip. M. Merkusheva. [In Russian].

9. Konfessional’naia politika sovetskogo gosudarstva. 1917–1991 : dokumenty i materialy : v 6 t. [The Confessional Policy of the Soviet State. 1917–1991 : Documents and Materials : in Six Volumes]. (2017). Moscow : ROSSPEN. [In Russian].

10. Lavrinov, V., Archpriest. (2018). Vremennyi Vysshy Tserkovnyi Sovet i ego rol’ v istorii Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi (1925–1945) [The Provisional Supreme Church Council and Its Role in the History of the Russian Orthodox Church (1925–1945)]. Moscow : Obshchestvo liubitelei tserkovnoi istorii. [In Russian].

11. Mazyrin, A., Priest. (2014). Kirill (Smirnov). In Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia (Vol. XXXIV, pp. 362–377). Moscow : TsNTs “Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia”. [In Russian].

12. Metropolitan Sergius (Stragorodsky). (2020). Tvoreniia [Creations]. Saint Petersburg : Izdatel’sky proekt “Kvadrivium”. [In Russian].

13. Pomestnyi sobor Rossiiskoi Pravoslavnoi tserkvi 1923 goda (obnovlencheskii). Biulleteni [The Local Synod of the Russian Orthodox Church in 1923 (Renovationist). Bulletins]. (1997). In Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi. Novyi patriarshii period (Vol. 1. 1917–1970, pp. 842–867). Saint Petersburg : Voskresenie. [In Russian].

14. Poslanie Sviateishego Pravitel’stvuiushchego Sinoda ko vserossiiskoi pastve : “K vernym chadam Pravoslavnoi Rossiiskoi Tserkvi” [The Message of the Holy Governing Synod to the All-Russian Flock : “To the Faithful Children of the Orthodox Russian Church”]. (1917). Tserkovnye vedomosti, (9–15), 57. [In Russian].

15. Radi mira tserkovnogo: Zhiznennyi put’ i arkhipastyrskoe sluzhenie sviatitelia Agafangela, mitropolita Iaroslavskogo, ispovednika. Kniga vtoraia [For the Sake of Church Peace: The Life Path and Archpastoral Ministry of St. Agafangel, Metropolitan of Yaroslavl, Confessor. Book Two]. (2006). Moscow : Izd-vo PSTGU. [In Russian].

16. Rogoznyi, P. G. (2018). Pravoslavnaia tserkov’ i russkaia revoliutsiia : ocherki istorii 1917–1920 [The Orthodox Church and the Russian Revolution : Essays on the History of 1917–1920]. Moscow: Ves’ mir. [In Russian].

17. Savva (Tutunov), Archbishop. (2011). Eparkhial’nye reformy : kruglyi stol po religioznomu obrazovaniiu i diakonii : diskussii v Pravoslavnoi Rossiiskoi Tserkvi nachala XX veka : Pomestnyi Sobor 1917–1918 gg. i predsobornyi period [Diocesan Reforms : a Round Table on Religious Education and Deaconry : Discussions in the Orthodox Russian Church of the Early Twentieth Century : The Local Council of 1917–1918 and the Pre-Council Period]. Moscow : Dukhovnaia biblioteka. [In Russian].

18. Safonov, D., Priest. (2019). Sviatitel’ Tikhon, patriarkh Moskovskii i vseia Rossii, i ego vremia [St. Tikhon, Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia, and His Time]. Moscow : Poznanie. [In Russian].

19. Sviatitel Tikhon. Patriarkh Moskovsky i vseia Rossii: sb. [St. Tikhon. Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia: [Collection]]. (2013). Moscow : Blagovest. [In Russian].

20. Sviashchennomuchenik Arkhiepiskop Ufimsky Andrei (Ukhtomsky). Trudy [Hieromartyr Archbishop Andrey of Ufa (Ukhtomsky). Works]. (2013). Saint Petersburg : Svoe izdatel’stvo. [In Russian].

21. Sviashchennomuchenik Iosif, mitropolit Petrogradsky: Zhizneopisanie i trudy [Hieromartyr Joseph, Metropolitan of Petrograd: Biography and Writings]. (2011). Moscow : Bratonezh; SPb.: Kifa. [In Russian].

22. Sevastianova, S. K. (2013). Povtornaia khirotoniia v traktovke patriarkha Nikona [Repeated Ordination in the Interpretation of Patriarch Nikon]. Sibirsky filologicheskii zhurnal, (4), 30–36. [In Russian].

23. Sergy (Stragorodsky), Archbishop. (1905). O sostave ozhidaemogo chrezvychainogo pomestnogo sobora russkoi Tserkvi [On the Composition of the Expected Extraordinary Local Council of the Russian Church]. Tserkovnyi vestnik, (51–52), 1608–1612. [In Russian].

24. Solovev, I., Priest. (2008). “Zhivaia tserkov’” [“The Living Church”]. In Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia (Vol. XIX, pp. 168–172). Moscow : TsNTs “Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia”. [In Russian].

25. Fedorov, V. A. (2005). Vserossiiskii soiuz demokraticheskogo dukhovenstva i mirian [All-Russian Union of Democratic Clergy and Laity]. In Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia (Vol. IX, p. 686). Moscow : TsNTs “Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia”. [In Russian].

26. Shkarovsky, M. V. (2011). Iosif (Petrovykh). In Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia (Vol. XXV, pp. 649–653). Moscow : TsNTs “Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia”. [In Russian].