His Holiness Patriarch Sergius, Metropolitan Gregory and the Theological Schools of the Moscow Patriarchy from 1944 to 2024

The article commemorates two significant events marking the 80th anniversary of the Russian Orthodox Church in 2024: the passing of His Holiness Patriarch Sergius and the establishment of the first theological schools in Moscow during the Soviet era. The question of establishing theological schools was raised by Patriarch Sergius following the Council of Bishops in 1943 and his subsequent election as patriarch. These schools were inaugurated just a month after his passing. It’s emphasized that the swift preparation for the opening of the Theological Institute and Theological and Pastoral courses was facilitated by the quarter-century journey of the patriarch’s long-time faithful colleague, Archpriest Nikolay Chukov (Archbishop Gregory of Saratov and Stalingrad), who authored the project for spiritual educational institutions of the Moscow Patriarchate. He had substantial experience in establishing and overseeing higher theological institutions in Petrograd-Leningrad from 1920 to 1925. For the first time, a diary detailing the activities of Archpriest Nikolay Chukov is published in the appendix. His endeavors, undertaken with the support of Metropolitan Sergius  and the Synod from 1928 to 1930, aimed to establish a Theological Institute in Leningrad. Unfortunately, his plans were thwarted by his arrest in 1930. The entries in the published diary confirm Olga Vasilyeva’s assertion that Metropolitan Sergius’ interview, which sparked widespread protests due to its denial of Church persecution in the USSR, was a quid pro quo for allowing him to submit a memo to Pyotr Smidovich. One of the memo’s points emphasized the necessity of opening a theological school. This memo played a pivotal role in obtaining permission, which, in turn, significantly hastened the process of opening theological schools in Moscow in 1943–1944. The article concludes with excerpts from books and articles by a professor from the Department of Church History at Saint Petersburg Theological Academy. This academic offers a negative and ironic assessment of both the ascetic work of Metropolitan Gregory of Leningrad and Novgorod, and the martyrdom of Patriarch Sergius, who endured humiliation primarily to preserve a legalized church organization, which was essential for the establishment of theological schools within the Patriarchate. This aspect became particularly significant when considering the pivotal choice by the authorities between the patriarchal Church and the Renovationists in 1943.

1. Akty Sviateishego Tikhona, Patriarkha Moskovskogo i vseia Rusi, pozdneishie dokumenty i perepiska o kanonicheskom preemstve vysshei tserkovnoi vlasti 1917–1943 gg. : v 2 ch. [Acts of His Holiness Tikhon, Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia, Later Documents and Correspondence on the Canonical Succession of the Supreme Church Authority of 1917– 1943. In 2 Parts] (Part 2). (1994). Moscow. [In Russian].

2. Aleksandrova-Chukova, L. K. (2022). Arkhiepiskop Grigory (Chukov) o polozhenii dukhovenstva k nachalu voiny, otkrytii sobora v Saratove i prieme v Kremle 4 sentiabria 1943 goda [Archbishop Grigory (Chukov) on the Situation of the Clergy at the Beginning of the War, the Opening of the Cathedral in Saratov and Reception in the Kremlin on September 4, 1943]. Vestnik tserkovnoi istorii, (1/2), 84–119. [In Russian].

3. Aleksandrova-Chukova, L. K. (2007). Mitropolit Grigory (Chukov): sluzhenie i trudy. K 50 letiiu prestavleniia [Metropolitan Gregory (Chukov): Ministry and Works. To the 50th Anniversary of his Repose]. Sankt Peterburgskie eparkhial’nye vedomosti, (34), 17–131. [In Russian].

4. Aleksandrova-Chukova, L. K., Zvonarev S., prot. (2021). Vysshee upravlenie Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi po dnevnikam protoiereia N. K. Chukova 1925–1930 gg. [The Supreme Administration of the Russian Orthodox Church According to the Diaries of Archpriest N. K. Chukov 1925–1930]. Vestnik tserkovnoi istorii, (1/2), 293–329. [In Russian].

5. Aleksandrova-Chukova, L. K. (2019). “Edinenie tsveta nauki i Tserkvi…”, ili Do Petrogradskogo protsessa 1922 g. i posle “Akademicheskogo dela” 1929–1931 gg. (po materialam dnevnikov mitropolita Grigoriia (Chukova) [“The Unity of the Best of Science and the Church...”, or Before the Petrograd trial of 1922 and after the “Academic Case” of 1929–1931 (based on the Diaries of Metropolitan Gregory (Chukov)]. Vestnik Ekaterinburgskoi dukhovnoi seminarii, (4), 324–396. [In Russian].

6. Aleksandrova-Chukova, L. K. (2023). Arkhiepiskop Grigory (Chukov) o Sobore episkopov 1943 g. i vedushchei roli patriarkha Sergiia v sokhranenii patriarshestva i edinstva Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi [Archbishop Grigory (Chukov) on the Council of Bishops in 1943 and the Leading Role of Patriarch Sergius in Preserving the Patriarchate and Unity of the Russian Orthodox Church]. Vestnik tserkovnoi istorii, (1/2), 86–144. [In Russian].

7. Aleksandrova-Chukova, L. K. (2020). Bogoslovsky institut v Petrograde (1920–1923 gg.) kak pervyi etap na puti vosstanovleniia dukhovnykh shkol v vide akademii i seminarii [The Theological Institute in Petrograd (1920–1923) as the First Stage Towards the Restoration of Theological Schools in the form of Academies and Seminaries]. Vestnik tserkovnoi istorii, (3/4), 251–330. [In Russian].

8. Aleksandrova-Chukova, L. K. (2006). Grigory (Chukov Nikolai Kirillovich, mitr. Leningradsky i Novgorodsky) [Grigory (Nikolai Kirillovich Chukov, Mitropolitan of Leningrad and Novgorod)]. In Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia (Vol. 12, pp. 592–598). Moscow. [In Russian].

9. Aleksandrova-Chukova, L. K. (2019). Petrogradsky protsess 1922 g. [Petrograd Process of 1922]. In Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia (Vol. 56, pp. 273–278). Moscow. [In Russian].

10. Aleksandrova-Chukova, L. K., Galkin A. K. (2021). “Ot pervogo litsa”: Bogoslovsko-pastyrskie kursy v Leningrade v dnevnikakh, rezoliutsiiakh i pis’makh mitropolita Grigoriia (K dvum 75-letnim iubileiam otkrytiia dukhovnykh shkol: 22 noiabria 1945 g. i 14 oktiabria 1946 g.) [“From the First Person”: Theological and Pastoral Courses in Leningrad in the Diaries, Resolutions and Letters of Metropolitan Gregory (For Two 75th Anniversaries of the Opening of Theological Schools: November 22, 1945 and October 14, 1946)]. Khristianskoe chtenie, (3), 68–89. [In Russian].

11. Vasileva, O. Iu. (2002). Fevral’skaia press-konferentsiia mitropolita Sergiia — istoricheskoe osmyslenie i istoricheskoe nasledie [February Press Conference of Metropolitan Sergius — Historical Understanding and Historical Heritage]. In Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi v XX veke (1917–1933 gg.): Materialy konferentsii v g. Sentendre (Vengriia) 13–16 noiabria n. st. 2001 g. (pp. 384–405). Munich. [In Russian].

12. Gregory (Chukov), Archbishop. (1943). Uchrezhdenie dukhovnouchebnykh zavedeny [Establishment of Theological Educational Institutions]. Zhurnal Moskovskoi Patriarkhii, (3), 22–24. [In Russian].

13. Gregory (Chukov), Archbishop. (2002). Finliandsky period deiatel’nosti Sviateishego Patriarkha Sergiia: 1905–1917 gg. [The Finnish Period of Activity of His Holiness Patriarch Sergius: 1905–1917]. Impersky kur’er, (2), 36–37. [In Russian].

14. Nikitin, D. N. (2018). “O religioznykh ob”edineniiakh” [“On Religious Associations”]. In Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia (Vol. 52, p. 201). Moscow. [In Russian].

15. Odintsov, M. I. (2013). Patriarkh Sergy [Patriarch Sergius]. Moscow. [In Russian].

16. Odintsov, M. I. (1999). Russkie patriarkhi XX veka. Sud’by Otechestva i Tserkvi na stranitsakh arkhivnykh dokumentov [Russian Patriarchs of the Twentieth Century. The Fate of the Fatherland and the Church on the Pages of Archival Documents]. Moscow. [In Russian].

17. Firsov, S. L. (2004). Apostasiia. “Ateist Aleksandr Osipov i vremia goneny na Russkuiu Pravoslavnuiu Tserkov’” [Apostasy. “The Atheist Alexander Osipov and the Time of Persecution of the Russian Orthodox Church”]. Saint Petersburg. [In Russian].

18. Firsov, S. L. (2005). Vremia v sud’be: Sviateishii Sergii, Patriarkh Moskovskii i vseia Rusi Sergii (Stragorodsky). O genezise “sergianstva” v russkoi tserkovnoi traditsii XX veka [Time in Fate: His Holiness Sergius, Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia Sergius (Stragorodsky). On the Genesis of “Sergianism” in the Russian Church Tradition of the XX century]. Saint Petersburg. [In Russian].

19. Firsov, S. L. (2023). Mifologicheskoe vospriiatie proshlogo: istoricheskaia nauka v kontekste legend i mifov [Mythological Perception of the Past: Historical Science in the Context of Legends and Myths]. Khristianskoe chtenie, (4), 163. [In Russian].